How To Cook Porgy On The Grill

How To Cook Porgy On The Grill

Grilling Porgy: Why It’s the Underappreciated Fish You Should Be Eating. Porgy, often referred to as Scup, represents a success story in species biomass recovery, boasting an increase of over 200 percent, as per the NOAA Fishwatch. In recent times, fishermen have found themselves actively avoiding areas dense with porgies due to their overwhelming numbers, which fill their nets with thousands of pounds of these fish. If your aim is to support sustainable seafood choices, porgy is the ideal option! Grilling Porgy: A Guide

Because Porgy is known for being bony, we never sold fillets at the fish stand. We have them filleted and sell both fillets and full Porgy at the market because there are so many around now and the fish Alex lands are bigger. Porgy is a panfish, which means its tiny size makes it ideal for pan-frying or steaming. This is also an excellent fish for baking whole in a salt crust.

I have noticed that the chefs are trying with new names for the same old Porgy: the newest is “Montauk sea bream.” That, I believe, is an indication of a species transitioning from “trash fish” to the desired entrée, as skate and monkfish have. Whether you like the name or not, get this fish on the grill and onto your plate this summertime with this tasty dish!

You will never have to worry about lukewarm meals again, thanks to the ubiquitous catering trick of chafing plates and the convenient cooking utensils you may already have in your home.

After five minutes, flip the meat over so that both sides can cook evenly. You can now use tongs or a spatula to turn the piece of meat every few minutes. If you are grilling multiple pieces of meat, make sure to leave some space between them so that they don’t steam each other.

This can vary depending on how much fat is on your meat. For example, if you have more fat on your ribs than the recommended amount, you should cook them at a lower temperature. If you have less fat, cook them at a higher temperature to sear and brown the surface of your meat. You can also make sure that you’re using an oven mitt when reaching for these ribs. This will prevent them from burning under your hand and prevent any unwanted flare-ups.

People often do wrong when grilling meat by touching it too much and moving it around too much. Don’t touch your food with your fingers, and always be gentle when using tongs or a spatula. Touching and tossing food might seem like a good idea because you think it will help cook it more evenly – but all you’re doing is making sure that there is no more juice left inside of your food!

Ingredients For The Dish To Cook Porgy On The Grill

  • five lemons
  • 4 entire (1 1/2 pound) porgies, boned and gutted (see Tips)
  • Salt
  • 8 fresh thyme sprigs
  • 4 fresh oregano sprigs
  • 6 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil, plus a little more for the grill grates
  • 2 bunches trimmed scallions

Preparation For The Dish To Cook Porgy On The Grill

  • Heat a charcoal grill to high or arrange a charcoal grill until the coals are ashed over and hot. Alternatively, preheat the broiler (see Tips).
  • Remove the pits from 3 lemons and cut them into 12-inch thick slices. Inside and out, pat the fish dry and season with salt. Put the lemon wedges within the fish, then top with the thyme and oregano. Tie the fish together in two positions with kitchen twine if it does not shut around the filling. 4 tablespoons olive oil, brushed over both sides of the fish
  • Toss the scallions with the other 2 tablespoons of olive oil and a sprinkle of salt. Remove the seeds from the remaining two lemons and cut them in half.
  • Clean the grill grate with an oiled dish towel or a bunch of paper towels. If your grill has enough space, put anything on at once. Alternatively, begin with the scallions and lemons, cut sides. Sprinkle one side of each fish with salt and set it on the grates, salt side down, next to the onions and lemons. Grill, rotating once until the lemons and scallions are softened and gently charred, 3 to 4 minutes for the scallions and 5 minutes for the lemons (covered if using a gas grill). Grill the fish for 6 minutes, or until the skin naturally releases from the grate, then salt the other side, cover, and grill for another 6 minutes, or until cooked through.
  • Slip a paring knife into the center of the fish to check for doneness; it should feel hot when delicately touched to your lower lip or the inside of your wrist.
  • On a serving tray, arrange scallions and lemon halves around the edges. Transfer the fish to a serving tray, cut the string, and serve.

Tips To Consider To Cook Porgy On The Grill

One should consider following tips that can help to cook Porgy on the grill without difficulty:

  • Orata, dorade, and sea bream are other names for porgies. Whole bluefish, tiny red snapper, or black sea bass can be used in place of the bluefish. Request that the fishmonger gut, bone, and scale the fish, resulting in a huge cavity for stuffing.
  • Broil everything on sheet pans 6 inches away from the heat source. You’ll need to work in batches, so begin with the scallions and lemon, then broil the fish, flipping once halfway through.


A giant fish makes an excellent dinner centerpiece, and smaller ones make extremely ample individual servings. And, at roughly two or three dollars per portion, it provides a lot of glitz for the buck. Whatever you do, you’ll wind up breaking a tiny piece of the skin and producing a sloppy mess as you grill. But that’s okay; just reserve a bit of the delicious green sauce and put it on top; it covers a multitude of sins.

There are affiliate links in this post. At no cost to you, I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.