Best Fish To Grill In Foil in 2024

If you are considering exploring with fish on the grill, it is important first to take the time to learn how best to grill fish on a grill. Unlike regular beef, grilling fish can be a stressful process for beginners. Seafood is generally more fragile than other types of meat, and the fact that it has bones throws a curveball to the whole process.

When it comes to grilling fish, it takes a bit of time to get it right if you have nothing to act as a guide. Lucky for you, this guide will show exactly how you can successfully grill fish and get it right the first time. Here is everything you need to know about grilling fish.

You will need a clean grill

Fish has been grilled over a fire for generations. This means that it is not a new phenomenon, and you, too, can get it right.

The first step to perfectly grilled fish is to start with a clean grill. Fish is a delicate type of meat that can be contaminated fast. Also, because of the softness of the meat, fish can easily stick onto your grill. A dirty grill is the easiest way to ruin a fish grilling session. Dirt on the grill easily attaches to the fish’s skin, making it difficult to turn your fish on the grill. By ensuring your grills is squeaky clean, you will avoid ruining the grilling process.

In addition, a dirty grill is the easiest way to burn your fish before it is properly cooked. This is because dirt residues on the grates can easily catch fire and transfer the heat to the surface of your fish. This will force the outer part to cook faster before the inside of the fish is well done. To avoid ruining an otherwise perfect fish, it is important to clean your grill before starting the grilling process.

The best fish to grill in foil

With a clean grill and a determination to learn, the other factor you need to consider is the best fish to grill in foil or open.

You can grill any type of fish. However, some cuts and types are more forgiving and easier to grill. This makes them perfect for beginners. These types of fish have a tougher flesh, which ensures they are less likely to fall apart while on the grill. You can get then in steak form or thick fillers. This thickness is what makes them better for grilling as they can withstand high temperatures.

It is important to note that the best grilling temperature for fish is medium heat. If you are stuck with normal fish and not the thick variety, you can ensure you grill them perfectly by wrapping then in foil. By so doing, you protect the fish from direct heat, which can be damaging. This ensures the fish evenly cooks through indirect heat through the foil. This is the best way to make delicate fish for beginners.

If you are using a gas grill, medium heat is about 350 F, which is equal to half a chimney of coal id you are grilling over charcoal. The best fish to grill in foil over charcoal or a gas grill include:

  • Swordfish
  • Halibut
  • Mahi-Mahi
  • Tuna
  • Salmon

Ensure you brush your foil with oil before wrapping your fish in it. Season the fish and allow it to grill for at least 8 minutes for every inch of thickness. Turn once halfway through the cooking process to ensure even cooking on all sides. Grilled wrapped in foil should be grilled using indirect heat.

When learning how to grill fish in foil, ensure the minimum thickness of your fish is at least one inch. The thicker the steak, the easier it is to grill. If you have marinated the fish, allow it to reach room temperature before grilling it.

Important tips for grilling fish in foil

Do not overdo it

Seafood and fish lack the muscle firmness present in other types of meat. Therefore, the marinade penetrates faster. Therefore, you should only marinate fish for a few hours. When cooking the fish, avoid leaving it on the fire for too long.


For most grill masters, fish is one of their biggest challenges. Even when you fail the first time, you can only perfect the skill by continuously trying again. As mentioned earlier, start with thick, firm fish before moving to the more delicate variations.

Feed your fire

This is an important tip when grilling fish in direct heat. When you are grilling fish with crust, you can use a bit more fire than you would on fish in foil. This helps to prevent the fish from sticking to the grates, thus making turning easy. Even so, do not make it too hot.

Minimize the flipping

Fish should be turned a maximum of two times while on the grill. Actually, it is recommended to turn fish once on the grill. This prevents the possibility of sticking on the grate from excessive turning.

Grill the first side for a bit longer

When grilling over direct heat, let it grill a minute longer than the second time. This allows it to cook well and develop a crust. Also, the second side does not need too much time to cook after the flip, since it was cooking before it was turned.

Always grill your fish with the lid closed.

Benefits of grilling fish

Nutrient retention

When you grill fish, you ensure that most of the nutrients are retained. This ensures you get your amino acids and other nutrients, which are important to your health.

You use less butter

Grilling fish in foil helps to lock in the moisture. This prevents the need to add more butter to your fish to enhance the taste and softness. This means that you eat fewer calories, making grilling an ideal method of cooking for healthy living.

Grilling is perfect for the outdoors

If you love grilling, you definitely love spending time in the outdoors. Nothing beats the feeling of enjoying perfectly grilled fish in the company of family and friends. Grilling encourages you to spend more time in the outdoors, which encourages your body to be active.



There are affiliate links in this post. At no cost to you, I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.