How To Toast A Sandwich In An Air Fryer For Everyone

Cooking grilled cheese in an air fryer will be fun once you understand how to toast a sandwich in an air fryer. A grilled cheese sandwich cooked in the air fryer is the perfect quick lunch or dinner. This is a hit with kids.

The Best Grilled Cheese In The Air Fryer

Grilled cheese sandwiches made in the air fryer are life-changing! Despite knowing it would work, we did not realize how well this technique worked for cheese melt sandwiches! They’re great snacks for kids or for a delicious lunch. I love the way the bread toasts and how the cheese melts. A lot of butter is not required. The bread toasts perfectly in the air fryer even with a little butter or olive oil.

How To Toast A Sandwich In An Air Fryer

1. This grilled cheese sandwich is so good and so easy to make in the air fryer. To make it:
2. On each slice of bread, place a slice of melting cheese. Spread butter on the outside of the sandwich and close it up. Spray lightly with olive oil spray.
3. The air circulating in the air fryer will cause the bread to fly off the sandwich if it is really thin and light. A toothpick can be used to secure a sandwich together. Make sure your toothpicks are removed before you eat!
4. Sandwiches should be placed in an air fryer and cooked.

Best Cheeses to Toast In A Sandwich in An Air Fryer

Make it super tasty by choosing a good melting cheese. American cheese is a great choice because it melts quickly and has a great flavor. Other good melting cheeses include fontina cheese, cheddar cheese, tuyere cheese, and Swiss cheese. Make sure you slice cheese thinly if you’re slicing it off a block. When melting cheese in an air fryer, thicker cheese takes longer. Thus, cook the cheese on lower heat, then toast the bread on a higher heat setting until it melts. In addition to butter, we lightly sprayed olive oil on the sandwiches. This helps the bread toast quicker. Different flavor options are great for both!

Recipes To Try For Toasted Sandwiches In An Air Fryer:

Here are a few recipes that you can try for yourself.

How To Toast A Cheese Sandwich In An Air Fryer

Cook time: 7 minutes ⃒ Serves: 1 ⃒ Per Serving: Calories 497, Carbs 11g, Fat 36g, Protein 30g

Ingredients:

• Bread slices – 2
• Cheddar cheese slices – 1
• Butter – 1 tbsp., softened
• Mozzarella cheese slices – 1
• Bacon slices – 2, cooked

Directions:

Spread butter on one side of bread slices. Place one bread slice into the multi-level air fryer basket. Arrange mozzarella cheese slice, bacon slices, and cheddar slice on top of the bread slice. Top with another bread slice. Place air fryer basket into the instant pot. Seal pot with air fryer lid. Select air fry mode and cook at 370 F for 4 minutes. Turn sandwich and air fry for 3 minutes more. Serve.

Nutella Sandwich

Cook time: 5 minutes ⃒ Serves: 2 ⃒ Per Serving: Calories 341, Carbs 42g, Fat 18g, Protein 4g

Ingredients:

• Bread slices – 4
• Nutella – 1/4 cup
• Butter – 1 tbsp., softened
• Banana – 1, cut into slices

Directions:

Spread butter on one side of each bread slices and place butter side down. Spread Nutella on another side of each bread slices. Place banana slices on 2 bread slices and top with remaining bread slices. Cut the sandwiches in half. Place the dehydrating tray in a multi-level air fryer basket. Place the air fryer basket into the instant pot. Place sandwiches on the dehydrating tray. Seal pot with the air fryer lid. Select air fry mode and cook at 370 F for 5 minutes. Turn sandwiches after 2 minutes. Serve.

 

Recipes To Enjoy With Air-Fried Sandwiches

Other recipes that can pair with the toasted sandwich,

Zucchini Crisps

Cook time: 12 minutes ⃒ Serves: 2 ⃒ Per Serving: Calories 124, Carbs 4g, Fat 7g, Protein 11g

Ingredients:

• Medium zucchini – 1, sliced 1/4–inch thick
• Parmesan cheese – ½ cup, grated
• Olive oil – 1 tbsp.

Directions:

Brush zucchini slices with oil and coat with parmesan cheese. Place zucchini slices into the multi-level air fryer basket and place basket into the instant pot. Seal pot with air fryer lid. Select air fry mode and cook at 370 F for 12 minutes. Serve.

Sweet Potato Fries

Cook time: 12 minutes ⃒ Serves: 2 ⃒ Per Serving: Calories 149, Carbs 27g, Fat 4g, Protein 2g

Ingredients:

• Medium sweet potatoes – 2, peeled and cut into the shape of fries
• Olive oil – 2 tsp.
• Black pepper – 1/8 tsp.
• Paprika – ¼ tsp.
• Garlic powder – ¼ tsp.
• Salt – ½ tsp.

Directions:

Add sweet potato fries into the mixing bowl and toss with the remaining ingredients. Place sweet potato fries into the multi-level air fryer basket and place basket into the instant pot. Seal pot with the air fryer lid. Select air fry mode and cook at 380 F for 12 minutes. Turn sweet potato fries halfway through. Serve.

Crispy Zucchini Fries

Cook time: 15 minutes ⃒ Serves: 4 ⃒ Per Serving: Calories 237, Carbs 23.7g, Fat 9.3g, Protein 15.1g

Ingredients:

• Zucchini – 1, cut into the shape of fries
• Black pepper – ½ tsp.
• Kosher salt – 1 tsp.
• Garlic powder – 1 tsp.
• Parmesan cheese – ¼ cup, grated
• Breadcrumbs – 1 cup
• Eggs – 2, lightly beaten

Directions:

Add egg in a shallow bowl. In a shallow dish, mix together breadcrumbs, cheese, garlic powder, pepper, and salt. Dip zucchini fries in egg then coat with breadcrumb mixture. Place coated zucchini fries into the multi-level air fryer basket and place basket into the instant pot. Seal pot with the air fryer lid. Select air fry mode and cook at 400 F for 15 minutes. Serve.

Conclusion

Grilled cheese sandwiches made in the air fryer are life-changing! Despite knowing it would work, we did not realize how well this technique worked for cheese melt sandwiches! They’re great snacks for kids or for a delicious lunch.